Research & knowledge · SKILL

Theory & Original Contribution Review

Review a theory’s main argument, contribution, evidence and logical coherence as an editor.

Skill introduction

For editors-in-chief, authors and research leads reviewing drafts, chapters or earlier material. Use the outline, readership, literature and examples to reconstruct the argument and separate existing positions, new contributions and evidence. Deliver an editorial decision and a plan for revision and verification.

How to verify the work

Check claims and counterexamples from the core problem through concepts and mechanisms to observable outcomes. Trace literature and authorship of earlier material. Record what the current draft adds, comparative evidence, empirical checks and open questions separately.

When to hand it over

Give evidence-based decisions to the author or lead editor. If authorship, key evidence or conditions for testing are missing, hold claims of originality or certainty and ask the author or a domain specialist to supply evidence.

What to measure

Count core claims with traceable sources and test conditions, and log breaks that remain in the argument after review.

What it does

Review the theory’s line of reasoning, contributions and evidence from its core problem to observable outcomes.

What it helps with

Identify existing ideas, genuinely new explanations and points requiring revision or testing.

Why it matters

Make theoretical contributions clear enough to discuss, test and revise.

PDF · Chinese

Guide

Core guidance, examples and a revision worksheet. PDF in Chinese.

V1.2 · 14 pages · 223 KB

Usage guide

Connect the fundamental question, concepts, mechanisms and observable results, then decide what to adopt and what needs revision or validation.

What to prepare

  • Contents, chapters, a research framework or proposed material.
  • Research scope, intended readers and existing literature and evidence.

What you receive

  • An assessment of the argument, contribution and theoretical coherence.
  • Editorial decisions, revision directions and a validation path.

Who it is for

  • Review a theoretical manuscript or research white paper.
  • Decide whether new material belongs in a framework.

How the work progresses

  1. 01

    Reconstruct the central question and argument.

  2. 02

    Examine claims, evidence and counterexamples separately.

  3. 03

    Decide what to adopt and specify revision and validation steps.

  4. 04

    When reviewing older drafts, log attribution, changes to the current text, comparisons with prior research and evidence of real-world effects separately before deciding what to adopt and where.

Getting started

This repository is private. A link does not grant access: use a GitHub account with the required permission. Private source files and installation packages are not provided here.

Scope and limits

  • This does not replace domain experts or peer review.
  • Limited material cannot prove priority or universal effectiveness; check literature and empirical evidence separately.

Updates for this Skill

Back to My Skills All updates

Follow this question further

How does co-creation become long-term cooperation?

  1. 01

    Research

    Research questions

    Clarify the question first.

  2. 02

    Systems design

    Theory & models

    Connect the elements and relationships.

  3. 03

    Planning

    Implementation plans

    Turn judgments into steps and conditions.

  4. 04

    Execution

    Work records

    Return to the field and record progress.

  5. 05

    Improvement

    Current page

    Methods & Skills

    Review the work and retain methods and standards.

SEARCH